A long post for the shortest day
by Max Akroyd
Sorry for the slight delay in posting! It’s been a befuddling time on the farm since we last spoke. Big changes have taken place in this household, most of them positive but all of them very distracting.
Readers of longstanding will recall that I aimed to feed myself from my field. Am I succeeding? The short is answer is: “no. I failed.” The long answer might be of interest to anyone interested in living off the land as a viable alternative to a distinctly non-viable, mainstream economy.
What went wrong/right
It’s difficult to discern success and failure when every endeavour seems to contain elements of both. As soon as October, however, it was apparent that my project wasn’t going to work out. ‘Real life’ (whatever that is) had intervened and disrupted the uninterrupted effort required to grow, cook and eat our own produce.
I can’t overstate, however, how well it had all been going up to that point. The generous weather, and the related abundance of soft fruit was a real help of course. It didn’t seem to matter if things like beans and sweetcorn were frazzling in the hot, dry summer when there were strawberries, gooseberries, currants, raspberries aplenty! This glut of fruit attracted the interest of our children who were soon grazing on the field for snacks and eating gooseberry ice cream for pudding. The best outcome of all was their realisation why we are doing what we are doing and their full participation in the processes of harvesting, processing and eating. They even did some weeding!
Distanced by recent events, it feels like a golden time. The dream came true and now stands in our collective memory as an ideal to be recaptured. We fitted seamlessly into a happy landscape populated by other happy animals working and living the land. What started as a solitary undertaking soon became a familial purpose (which is another way of saying they ate all my strawberries!). The tastes and textures of life became subtle and robust all at once. I soon discovered that it doesn’t matter if you only have a bit of meat and some potatoes and something green to eat as long as they are the best. This way you can enjoy pretty much the same thing every day if you have to - many peasant cultures do. Now I understand how and why. Contrast this with eating devitalised supermarket fare which makes you crave endless variety. Or just plain more.
It’s a lot of hard work though – exhausting actually. The comforting idea of preserving the harvest loses its aura if you’ve already been on your feet all day growing it. Ideally, you’d inherit land worked by previous generations and have an extended family to share the baby, and other pressing commitments, around. In these (and many other) respects we were just not ready. By its nature, the Rural Idiocy? project was a simulation, a self-imposed test. It proved difficult to maintain this illusion while the rest of the world continued with real life (for now). Bills still needed paying and the kids kept growing out of their clothes… I suspect neither of those things were so significant for the real peasants of yore.
Reality bites
By midsummer the money ran out. Very early one summer morning, Emma – who finds poverty infuriating – baked a range of things, got in the car, got out of the car to jump start it and then set off to a local market. She’s been doing this – selling baked things and sewn things to French people in French – ever since. She’s kept the wolf from the door – and I’ve been kept behind that door trying to contain our toddler turbocharged by homegrown produce! It’s been a pleasure making his acquaintance properly, but the garden did soon suffer.
This neglect was compounded when I became embroiled in a complex legal dispute. I can’t say much more about it except I’m owed money. I’ve had to do a lot of learning about French language and French law in the the last six months and this distraction above all others killed an already tattered project stone dead. C’est la vie, as we used to say in Keighley. But when your new old life is invaded by responsibilities from your old new one, it’s hard not to feel a bit cheated.
Making eggs out of an omelette
If you want to “go back to the land”, it’s useful to acknowledge why so many people left the land in the first place and continue to do so in poorer parts of the world.
Fact is, the idiocy of rural life remains a dour struggle. At times the work can be back-breaking and lonely and boring. Freedom from wage slavery can also mean freedom from cash and new shoes for the kids. The muddy path to self-sufficiency seems to always stretch out in the opposite direction to the neon-signposted one which says “money this way”. It’s either cash or carrots: two incompatible goals in life, it seems. Smallholders with fewer than two surnames have to add a business venture to their rural escapade to make ends meet. Almost invariably this involves selling something homely, but non-essential, to fellow human beings who remain wage-slaves. In other words you’re still reliant upon the health of the wider economy.
Oh dear. Not going so well in the real world, is it? Sometimes it’s been hard to ascertain which version of living represents a reckless, Utopian, delusion. Back in 2008, brave politicians should have ignored the bleatings of donors and lobbyists and declared this international bankruptcy, defaulted and reset. Instead we are confronted with an undeclared insolvency magnified every day by cowardly things like quantative easing. Unresolved insolvency isn’t a static thing, something that happened in 2008: it’s dynamic – like a vortex – pulling in more and more things of value until the fabric of modern life collapses. No, we’re not ready for that either!
I felt all marginal and peculiar responding to a notion of economic collapse a few years back. Now you can read all about it in the mainstream media. I don’t feel vindicated if the sky still can fall on my head. To paraphrase an ancient Chinese proverb: “The best time to prepare for global economic collapse is ten years ago. The next best time is now.”
The return
Not very uplifting is it? Crashing out of the encapsulated safety of suburban existence back into the sweating, bleeding core of normal human experience was never going to be a barrel of laughs. And that’s certainly been our experience here at the end of world (aka Finistère). That concludes the report from the advance party down the slippery slope.
But there is, I believe, a glimmer of hope. Most people know that food you grow yourself tastes better – the true texture and flavour of things rediscovered through hard graft. As everything from nurseries to nursing homes close down, and families are forced back together, perhaps we’ll also regain some thing similar, something invigorating we didn’t know we’d lost. The true and difficult quality of life will be restored. Maybe a safe, sanitised and moneyed existence wasn’t that secure, salubrious or rich after all. The alternative is messy, labourious and unglamorous – just like people are really. Welcome home.
Rural Idiocy? 2.0
I’ll be resuming proper blogging on 12th January 2012. There’ll be a new Rural Idiocy? website by then too – but the blog will continue right here. The general aim remains the same: to find a safe mooring for my family as the storm approaches. Thanks to my M.A. in subsistence setbacks awarded by the University of Rural Life, I think I’ve finally got the measure of this growing food malarkey. I’ll be recording everything I do, whilst trying to consolidate that fragmented knowledge into a coherent whole. Who knows? It might be useful to others. But no big plans or promises this time. I learnt that too.
I almost forgot to mention the garden. It’s now in the best shape it’s ever been. The overwintering peas and beans are in. I’ve dug a dozen big new beds for roots and the pigs and plough have prepared a huge area for spuds and for everything else which will go in a trench. The polytunnel and greenhouse stand ready for the season to come. And so do we.
Just space left to wish a happy solstice to anyone and everyone who is reading this. Who knows what the next year will bring? But at least, from today, the light is returning and that cannot be stopped.

Reality bites. It’s a sad fact but ‘these days’ it’s harder than ever before to live the Good Life. I don’t even believe it was that good but a dream of days gone by, which, like you say, the rural population left for the city as the dream, in reality is a hard, cold slog. In summer, perfect, but winter brings a time to think and lack of money and children to feed, the wolf at the door, sharpens the focus on what is do-able.
It’s admirable what you set out to do and have achieved, so a big pat on the back for that and don’t give up, just remodel. You have my support, from afar – Bruges this time. So take care and a Very Merry Christmas to you all.
Hi Helen, and thank you for the thoughtful reply.
At the beginning of this I knew that both industrial and rural lives lived in their pure form were not for me. I think I’d hoped for some happy synthesis of the two. I suppose this is me realising they’re, in fact, immiscible and having to just plod on anyway! (Under-rated group the plodders-on, I think)
In which case, support from afar (or near) is the best gift we could receive this xmas.
I will now go and look at Bruges on a map so I know what it is!
Happy Christmas from everyone here,
Max
Nice to have you back and I look forward to January 2012, when we can follow each others adventures once again.
Life has moved on for all of us in your long absence. We’ve lost someone dear, had to change all our plans (which included re-homing all our rare breed pigs), sat back , took stock and have decided to down scale, to save up for our very own place. We move in February to our new 4 acre patch, contracts are being signed this Friday.
That you tried your plans and briefly achieved them is a tribute to you and your family, that you held your hands up when they started crumbling is an even bigger tribute and that you are not brow-beaten enough to give up completely is to be applauded – loudly.
I wish you and yours a wonderful festive season, may the New Year bring us all bigger and better things.
Lovely to have you back.
Sue xx
Hi Sue,
I want to say sorry that I haven’t been around these last months. I’ve been in a parallel world, preoccupied with this big legal thing. That’s now in the hands of a higher authority, so hopefully there will be time to catch up with the outside world in general and all your developments in particular.I’ve really missed your online support so I’ll try and do a better job of warranting it in future.
As regards the plan, I guess success is the thing that happens after the grandiose plans are gone. 2012? Bring it on!
See you there! Happy Christmas from everyone here,
Max
Lots in this. The strongest thought I go away with is the importance of community – in the small and large scale. We are bound together economically. It’s annoying but also inspiring. We humans need each other.
Not clear how you are supporting yourselves. Was expecting you to say you have moved. But you are still there. Is it by the making and selling? If so – that would also have been part of an old-style rural economy, surely?
I wish you had been able to keep a blog going through all this. Have often wondered how you are doing.
Best wishes for Christmas, the New Year, the children, both of you – everything.
Esther
Hello Esther,
Thank you for taking the time to consider what I wrote.
I do take your point about community. But I also think it’s become a bit of a political contrivance in recent times: ‘building community’ always sounds a bit hollow to me, like ‘learning empathy’. It’s not the thing it purports to be if it’s not spontaneous.(However, such concepts are admittedly not my strong suits by nature.)
Perhaps the rediscovery of authentic community will be the good outcome wrapped up in a lot of bad outcomes?
I believe a rural economy can work, based as you say on the making and selling of things. It’s the co-existence with the industrial economy which is problematic. Most of these problems would go away post-collapse. Then we won’t be looted by energy companies and everyone’s children can run around happily with trousers at half mast!
Have a great Christmas,
Max
Hi Max
Only just read this. It started to make me feel very sad after all the hard work that you have both put in, but then right at the end I could see hope. That is fantastic!
Anyone who has followed your blog will have shared your ups & downs. I know that living it & reading about it is not the same, but some of us did worry about you at times.
I for one,am look forward to chapter 2 .
I hope you all have a marvellous Christmas & a very productive New Year.
Mary
Hi Mary,
It’s strange to be at the start of chapter two without a clue about how it’s going to end – and I’m meant to be the author!
Please never worry though, I’m good at making things up as I go along. In fact, having no plan is now the plan!
We’re both very pleased to have you on board in a virtual sense as we set off to who knows where?
Have a great day tomorrow,
Max
Hi Max
Great to see you’re back on the web.
I have greatly missed reading your updates and am sorry to see things didn’t work out the way you had planned. We are great admirers of your experiment and are delighted that you are looking forward to a new beginning.
I agree with your comments re communities etc. it seems that we forget that community in the traditional sense was really a survival system which was replaced by modern industrial living. What you are trying to do without the support of either the “traditional” or the modern industrial “community” is admirable but understandably extremely difficult.
This has also been my experience of rural living in the west of Ireland, albeit on a slightly less ambitious scale to yours. It seems that because everyone now lives in an encapsulated individual family unit it is nearly impossible to get any assistance for anything without having ready cash to pay for it. In short this means only one thing as you have noted, the necessity of paid work for wages/salary.
Rural people in our area seem to have figured this out long ago and I am now beginning to understand why they adopt such a sceptical view of all “modern new-age types” talking of self-sufficiency etc !
Whatever about that, well done to you both for your efforts, I hope it all works out for you and please keep up the blog. Whenever I have been ready to despair with my own garden I have always gone back to your blog and got great inspiration from your efforts and determination.
All the best and have a happy Christmas
From Conor, Olga and Kids, Westport, Co. Mayo.
Hi Conor & family,
Your insight is much appreciated and has really moved on my understanding of this situation we’re in.
As I’m writing this, dawn is doing strange and wonderful things with the sky. I don’t know what we’d do without that direct rapport with nature offered by this lonely, western place.
So please be assured that I intend to try and solve the conundrum of how to make ends meet without negating the possibility of living off the land – which is, of course, the only real way to make ends meet!
Thank you for all those very kind words. Happy Christmas from everyone here,
Max
A meaning of Christmas rediscovered.
Well, I think you did far better than you think you did… experience counts and perhaps, down the road, you’ll look up and realize you arrived where you wanted to be and didn’t even know it.
Changes my end too, family farm has now gone, sad but necessary, but feels as if my “water rat” roots have been cut. Hey ho, life meanders on its way and the journey is nothing, if not intriguing
Well done, Max and happy new year to you all
Kate x
That’s a very kind response Mrs T. And I’m sorry to hear about the farm. The importance of roots is easy to underestimate. I know I did!
Hi Max and family
I agree with Mrs T that you probabbly have achieved all that you set out to achieve; and, certainly, the selling of baked and sewn things, jams, chutneys and anything else that you can produce with surpluses, has to be a part of living off the land. Like you legalities have got in the way of our plans this year, but, also like you, the New Year brings the next chance to get it all right, and to fail in a whole different set of ways. Enjoy trying, and, as long as you have your family and your health it will be well worth the effort.
Peter
Hi Peter,
And sorry for taking so long to reply. Christmas and related travel has taken up all my time recently.
I agree about the commercial aspect of things. It just becomes endangered if the profit hard-won at market goes straight into the petrol tank to get you home. It would be ironic to be paddling away in the lifeboat only to get pulled under when the big ship goes down!
Must row harder!
Max
It’s January 12 Max, and I’m looking forward to walking the next path in step with you and Emma. What is life if not a series of journeys? Judith.
Funny you should mention that Judith..!